Skip to main content

Posts

Learning to listen and listening to learn

This week I want to dig into the purpose of listening in our language lessons, and where that takes us When I first started teaching, I was using Studio for French and Echo for German (later on I started to teach Spanish too, and worked from Viva). I noticed even in my training year the pattern whereby a set of vocabulary and grammar was the learning outcome for the double page spread. To start with this would be introduced passively - it seemed to alternate between a bit of reading and a bit of listening first, and then the other would come. Then the students would be expected to produce what they had learned.  It struck me as making perfect sense: the students were very clearly listening to learn whatever the language point(s) were for that particular lesson or series of lessons.  So one of the key reasons why we listen, then, is to learn. From a language-learning point of view, that might be listening to learn the language, like the example I have just given above. Or, mor...

How listening isn’t reading - and where that might take us

As I said to my daughter ‘I’m going to write a blog about how listening isn’t reading’, she said ‘well, obviously.’ But of course there’s a lot more to it than that. The types of tasks that are set in the language classroom (regardless of target language) might well suggest that listening tasks are identical to reading tasks, with the only difference that the passages are heard by the student rather than read. In my context - teaching French, German and occasionally Spanish to students in an English secondary school, one would be forgiven to assume, therefore, that listening is simply ‘heard reading’. And indeed, the types of passages that my students are exposed to from the exercise books and then in the exams, this is largely the case (a little bit less than it was, perhaps, but still largely the case). The inherent wrongness of this approach is fodder for a different blog post and will no doubt form a thread throughout all the posts on this blog. So rather than dipping into what on ...

Listening and self-subtitling

At each of the 20 interview times, I asked my four case studies what they were experiencing as they were listening to French. At the end of year seven, one of them – Helen, told me ‘ Usually when I’m listening  – especially in French – I can see the words in my head.’. This wasn’t something I’d heard of before and it intrigued me, so I began to check in on this phenomenon regularly. Often with Helen it seemed to be that she could identify individual words that she didn’t know, and these the ones that she ‘saw’ spelled out in her minds eye. That seemed to help her ‘park’ those words and gave her the ability to come back to them later and build meaning even though the echo memory had passed. She said she didn’t control it – the phrases she struggled with would just ‘pop up’ (her words) in her mind eye, quite automatically.  My conversations with Helen made me wonder how unusual this was – there’s some academic research into the idea of ‘Inner Experience’ from academics Heavey an...

The translation reflex

  When we are experienced listeners of a language, we understand what is being said automatically, much the same as when we listen to our first language in optimum conditions (i.e. not with a lot of background noise or distractions). In other words, we move straight from words to meaning without taking a detour. But many beginner listeners of a second language don’t do this; instead, it seems they are furiously scurrying to TRANSLATE everything they have heard into their first language(s). As you can imagine, this has a range of interesting effects.  Some researchers have gone so far as to say that mental translation is ‘a strategy that beginning-level listeners feel compelled’ to use (Vandergrift, Goh, Mareschal, & Tafaghodtari, 2006:450) - it’s hard to tell from this idea of compulsion whether it’s a reflex, or whether it’s more a sense of obligation. My own sense is that a lot of beginner listeners will translate almost automatically, and they can’t help it. After all, ...

How listening works

  If you want to improve your teaching of listening, it’s a good idea to have a sense of what we know about what goes on between the moment that the message made by a human voice hits your ear drum, until the moment in which you form meaning from it. Anderson, writing in 1990, came up with a ‘three phase model’ consisting of ‘perceptual processing’, ‘parsing’ and ‘utilisation’: in layman’s terms meaning that firstly you recognise the sound as familiar language, then you break the sound into words and chunks, and finally you give meaning to them, and / or act on them in some way. Later, Cutler and Clifton split up the ‘parsing’ section into two: firstly ‘segmenting’ – breaking the up the continuous stream of what you hear into individual words – and secondly ‘recognising’, which is the process of using your mental dictionary to look up the words. Most recently, John Field has been the world expert in second language listening. His book Listening In The Language Classroom (2008) gi...

A back story

  When I began my MSc at Oxford in 2015, I never thought my journey would take me to a DPhil, and never imagined that if it did, it would be in the developmental trajectory of listening. Still, the presentation of a single study – Graham & Macaro (2008) – peaked my interest as I saw the relevance of the research questions to my own context as a teacher of French in an English secondary school. A Master’s dissertation about the experiences of listening to French as a lower intermediate English learner (Simpson, 2017) showed me the excitement of trying to grasp what happens in the listener’s mind when they hear French, with all the intriguing nuances that this brings. A rainy evening in the university library at the start of my DPhil. The full-time students have long since gone home, and another paper captures my imagination. For practical reasons I am doing the DPhil part-time, and continuing to work, and want to make a virtue of my part-time status by looking at the progres...